1099 vs. W-2: Independent Contractor or Employee? in Utah
The IRS, state agencies, and the Department of Labor all separately judge whether a worker is an independent contractor (1099) or an employee (W-2). Getting it wrong costs back wages, unpaid payroll taxes, penalties, and interest.
What's specific to Utah
- Corporate tax
- Flat 4.55% corporate income tax (matches personal rate).
- Sales tax
- 6.1% — Combined rates 6.5-9% with local add-ons.
- ★Among the cheapest LLC fees in US
- ★Flat income & corporate rates
2026 published rates. Verify with Utah agencies before filing.
The IRS common law test
The IRS evaluates behavioral control (who decides how the work is done?), financial control (who provides tools? who has unreimbursed expenses? is the worker available to the market?), and relationship (written contracts, benefits, permanency, and core-business integration).
State ABC tests are stricter
California (AB 5), New Jersey, Massachusetts, and several other states use the ABC test: a worker is an employee unless (A) free from control, (B) work is outside the hiring entity's usual business, and (C) the worker is independently established in that trade. Most workers fail prong B.
Cost of misclassification
Federal: back FICA (7.65% employer share), federal income tax withholding, FUTA, plus 100% penalty under §3509. State: back unemployment insurance, state withholding, workers' comp premiums, and disability insurance. DOL: back overtime and minimum wage under FLSA. Total exposure often 30–40% of payments to the worker.
Key takeaways
- ✓Federal IRS test ≠ state ABC test. Comply with both.
- ✓Misclassification penalty can hit 30–40% of contractor payments.
- ✓When in doubt, classify as W-2 — it's cheaper than getting it wrong.
Utah resources
- • Utah Secretary of State — business registrations & annual reports
- • Utah Department of Revenue — state tax filings & rates
- • Utah Department of Labor — wage, hour, and unemployment
Need a Utah contract?
iContract drafts Utah-specific agreements in under 60 seconds, free to try.
Start drafting free