Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs): Use or Abuse? in Pennsylvania
A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a structured written agreement giving an underperforming employee a defined period (typically 30, 60, or 90 days) to meet specific goals — or face termination. Done well, it's a fair last chance; done poorly, it's pre-litigation paperwork.
What's specific to Pennsylvania
- State unemployment (SUTA)
- SUTA wage base $10,000; employees also contribute 0.07%.
- Workers' compensation
- Required for any employee; private + State Workers' Insurance Fund.
- ★Corporate tax stepping down to 4.99% by 2031
- ★New $7 annual report requirement
2026 published rates. Verify with Pennsylvania agencies before filing.
When a PIP is appropriate
Documented pattern of underperformance (not a single incident). Performance issues that are coachable, not character/integrity issues. Issues that a reasonable employee could reasonably correct in 30–90 days with clear guidance. Not appropriate for serious misconduct, theft, harassment, or safety violations — those warrant immediate action.
Writing a defensible PIP
Specific, measurable goals (not 'improve attitude'). Concrete examples of past performance gaps. Clear deadlines and check-in dates. Defined support: training, resources, mentor. Clear consequences for not meeting goals. Acknowledgment line for employee signature.
Manager obligations during the PIP
Weekly written check-ins documenting progress. Honest mid-PIP assessment. If the employee is meeting goals, the PIP must end successfully — moving the goalposts mid-PIP destroys legal defensibility. If the employee is not meeting goals, document specifically why.
Legal protection — and risk
A properly executed PIP is strong evidence in wrongful termination defense. A PIP started right after FMLA leave, a discrimination complaint, or accommodation request is presumptive retaliation and worse than no PIP at all. Time PIPs based on performance facts, not in response to protected activity.
Key takeaways
- ✓PIPs are for coachable performance issues, not misconduct.
- ✓Specific, measurable goals with weekly written check-ins.
- ✓Never start a PIP right after protected activity (leave, complaint).
Pennsylvania resources
- • Pennsylvania Secretary of State — business registrations & annual reports
- • Pennsylvania Department of Revenue — state tax filings & rates
- • Pennsylvania Department of Labor — wage, hour, and unemployment
Need a Pennsylvania contract?
iContract drafts Pennsylvania-specific agreements in under 60 seconds, free to try.
Start drafting free