Harassment vs. Discrimination: The Legal Difference That Matters
Four legal theories, four different sets of evidence. Getting them confused kills cases and defenses.
Harassment: two flavors
Quid pro quo — an employment benefit conditioned on tolerating unwelcome conduct (usually sexual). One incident can be enough. Hostile work environment — severe or pervasive conduct based on a protected class that alters conditions of employment. Requires a pattern in most cases.
Discrimination: two theories
Disparate treatment — intentional. Similarly situated employees treated differently because of a protected class. Disparate impact — a facially neutral policy that disproportionately affects a protected class. No intent required.
Employer defense
Faragher-Ellerth: for hostile-environment claims where no tangible employment action was taken, the employer may avoid liability by (1) having an anti-harassment policy with a reporting mechanism and (2) proving the plaintiff unreasonably failed to use it.