Landmark Contract Cases, Explained

    Eight cases every contract drafter should know, what each held, and the clause that addresses it. General information, not legal advice.

    Hadley v. Baxendale

    (1854) 9 Exch. 341 (England) · Foreseeable damages

    Rule: A party in breach owes only damages that arise naturally from the breach or that both sides reasonably contemplated when they contracted.

    Drafting lesson: Use a limitation-of-liability clause that excludes or caps consequential damages, and disclose unusual risks up front.

    See the related clause →

    Lucy v. Zehmer

    196 Va. 493 (1954) · Objective theory of assent

    Rule: A contract is formed by what parties outwardly say and do, not by secret intent — a 'joke' sale written and signed was binding.

    Drafting lesson: Treat every signed writing as binding; state clearly when a document is only a draft or non-binding term sheet.

    See the related clause →

    Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.

    [1893] 1 Q.B. 256 (England) · Unilateral offers

    Rule: A public offer of a reward can be accepted by performing the stated conditions, without notifying the offeror.

    Drafting lesson: Define precisely what counts as acceptance and performance in offers, promotions and bonus plans.

    See the related clause →

    Hawkins v. McGee

    84 N.H. 114 (1929) · Expectation damages

    Rule: Damages put the injured party where they would have been had the promise been kept.

    Drafting lesson: Describe deliverables and outcomes specifically, and disclaim guarantees you are not making.

    See the related clause →

    Jacob & Youngs v. Kent

    230 N.Y. 239 (1921) · Substantial performance

    Rule: Trivial, unintentional deviations do not excuse payment; the remedy is the difference in value.

    Drafting lesson: If an exact specification matters, say it is an express condition of payment.

    See the related clause →

    Taylor v. Caldwell

    (1863) 3 B. & S. 826 (England) · Impossibility

    Rule: Performance is excused when the specific thing it depends on is destroyed without fault.

    Drafting lesson: Add a force majeure clause listing the events and the notice and termination steps that apply.

    See the related clause →

    Raffles v. Wichelhaus

    (1864) 2 H. & C. 906 (England) · Mutual misunderstanding

    Rule: No contract forms when a key term is ambiguous and each side reasonably meant something different.

    Drafting lesson: Define key terms — dates, places, units, products — so there is only one reasonable reading.

    See the related clause →

    Williams v. Walker-Thomas Furniture Co.

    350 F.2d 445 (D.C. Cir. 1965) · Unconscionability

    Rule: Courts may refuse to enforce terms that are grossly unfair and that one side had no meaningful choice to accept.

    Drafting lesson: Keep one-sided terms proportionate and conspicuous, especially in consumer agreements.

    See the related clause →