Hiring Your First Employee
Payroll turns your business into a regulated employer overnight. The IRS, your state, and the Department of Labor all have paperwork due before the first paycheck.
The roadmap
- 1
Before the offer
Get the legal accounts in place.
- •Register with your state's employer withholding + unemployment insurance
- •Buy workers' compensation insurance (required in 49 of 50 states)
- •Choose a payroll provider (Gusto, ADP, QuickBooks)
- 2
The offer
Documents the employee signs before their first day.
- •Written offer letter (at-will, comp, start date, exempt/non-exempt)
- •Employment agreement or handbook acknowledgment
- •Confidentiality + IP assignment agreement
- 3
Day one
Federal forms every new hire completes.
- •Form I-9 (identity + work authorization, within 3 days)
- •Form W-4 (federal withholding)
- •State withholding form
- •Direct deposit authorization
Documents you'll need
Things to consider
- Misclassifying a W-2 employee as a 1099 contractor is the #1 audit trigger for small businesses.
- Every state has its own final-paycheck timing rule — some require same-day payment on termination.
- Exempt vs. non-exempt is a legal test, not your preference.
When to talk to a lawyer
- • You're hiring someone with equity
- • Employee is coming from a direct competitor
- • You're hiring across state lines (nexus + payroll registration in each state)
- • The role involves protected information (PHI, financial data)
Frequently asked
1099 or W-2?
The IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control, and the relationship — not what you call it. When in doubt, W-2 is the safer classification.
Related life events
Last reviewed July 2026 · US federal + state overview. We update this page when laws change; we don't replace it.