New York · Payroll Tax

    1099 vs. W-2 — The Tax Consequences in New York

    Whether a worker is a 1099 contractor or W-2 employee dramatically changes who pays what tax — and getting it wrong creates IRS liability for the business plus state and federal penalties.

    What's specific to New York

    Personal income tax
    4%–10.9% graduated state income tax + NYC adds up to 3.876%.
    Corporate tax
    6.5% corporate franchise tax (7.25% for >$5M income) + capital base + fixed minimums.
    Sales tax
    4% — Combined rates 7-8.875% (NYC is 8.875%).
    • ★NYC adds its own income tax
    • ★LLC publication requirement is expensive in NYC counties

    2026 published rates. Verify with New York agencies before filing.

    1099 contractor — tax responsibility

    Contractor pays 100% of SE tax (15.3% on first $168,600 net), all federal and state income tax, and is responsible for quarterly estimated payments. Employer pays only the contract amount — no FICA match, no FUTA, no SUTA, no benefits.

    W-2 employee — tax split

    Employer pays half of FICA (7.65%), FUTA (~0.6% effective), SUTA (varies), workers' comp, and benefits as offered. Employee pays half of FICA, federal/state income tax via withholding, no quarterly payments required.

    Cost comparison

    A $100K W-2 employee costs employer ~$112–118K all-in (FICA, FUTA, SUTA, WC, benefits). A $100K 1099 contractor costs employer $100K but typically requires 15–25% higher rate to compensate the contractor for SE tax and lack of benefits — so true cost is similar at $115–125K.

    Reclassification consequences

    If the IRS reclassifies a 1099 worker as a W-2 employee, the employer owes back FICA, federal withholding, FUTA, plus penalties up to 100% of withholding under §3509. State piles on back SUTA, workers' comp premiums, and overtime under FLSA. Total exposure typically 30–40% of payments made.

    Key takeaways

    • ✓1099 = contractor pays all 15.3% SE tax.
    • ✓W-2 = employer pays half of FICA + FUTA + SUTA.
    • ✓Reclassification can cost 30–40% of contractor payments in back taxes.

    New York resources

    Need a New York contract?

    iContract drafts New York-specific agreements in under 60 seconds, free to try.

    Start drafting free