S-Corp vs. LLC: The Tax Comparison in Pennsylvania
An LLC is a legal entity. S-corp is a tax election that an LLC or corporation can make. The S-corp election can save significant self-employment tax — but only above a certain profit threshold and only if you actually run payroll for yourself.
What's specific to Pennsylvania
- Personal income tax
- Flat 3.07% personal income tax (one of the lowest flat rates).
- Corporate tax
- 8.49% Corporate Net Income Tax (declining toward 4.99% by 2031).
- Sales tax
- 6% — Philadelphia adds 2% (8%); Allegheny adds 1% (7%); otherwise uniform 6%.
- ★Corporate tax stepping down to 4.99% by 2031
- ★New $7 annual report requirement
2026 published rates. Verify with Pennsylvania agencies before filing.
How LLC taxation works by default
Single-member LLC = disregarded entity = report on Schedule C, pay SE tax on 100% of net profit. Multi-member LLC = partnership = each member pays SE tax on their distributive share of ordinary income.
How S-corp taxation works
Owner takes a W-2 'reasonable salary' subject to FICA (7.65% employee + 7.65% employer). Remaining profit flows through on K-1 free of FICA. The W-2 portion is the only payroll-tax-bearing income.
The break-even calculation
Annual S-corp costs: ~$1,500–3,000 for payroll service, tax prep, and state franchise tax. SE tax saved: (Net profit − Reasonable salary) × 15.3%. Break-even is typically around $40–50K of net profit. Above $80K, S-corp usually nets $5–15K/year of savings.
Reasonable salary — the IRS gotcha
S-corp owners must pay themselves a 'reasonable salary' based on what someone else would charge for similar work in similar geography. Setting salary too low (e.g., $20K on $200K net) is the #1 trigger for S-corp audit. Use BLS, Glassdoor, or RCReports to document.
Key takeaways
- ✓LLC = legal entity. S-corp = tax election.
- ✓S-corp saves SE tax — costs ~$2K/year in compliance.
- ✓Break-even around $40–50K net profit.
- ✓Don't lowball reasonable salary — it triggers audits.
Pennsylvania resources
- • Pennsylvania Secretary of State — business registrations & annual reports
- • Pennsylvania Department of Revenue — state tax filings & rates
- • Pennsylvania Department of Labor — wage, hour, and unemployment
Need a Pennsylvania contract?
iContract drafts Pennsylvania-specific agreements in under 60 seconds, free to try.
Start drafting free